top of page

Athlete Perfectionism Explained by a Sport Psychologist [9 Tips to Cope]

athlete perfectionism

Are you tired of feeling like you're never quite good enough, even when you perform well? Hi there, I'm Dr. Matthew Myrvik, a sports psychologist specializing in athlete perfectionism. With a Ph.D. in Clinical Psychology and years of experience working with elite athletes, I've developed proven strategies to help athletes and coaches navigate the pitfalls of perfectionism. In this post, I'll delve into the concept of athlete perfectionism and provide tangible tips for changing these patterns to optimize performance and well-being. Let's embark on this journey together toward healthier and more fulfilling athletic endeavors.

Understanding athlete perfectionism

Perfectionism in sports means always trying to be perfect, but it can be both helpful and harmful for athletes. Athletes feel pressure to do everything perfectly, from their skills to their mental game. This pressure often comes from coaches, teammates, and even society's expectations. It can lead to stress, anxiety, and burnout. But, understanding where this pressure comes from can help athletes and coaches work together to find better ways to succeed. Here are some common sources of perfectionism:

  • High expectations from coaches and teammates

  • Pressure to meet societal standards of success

  • Fear of failure and criticism

By recognizing these sources of pressure, athletes can start to develop healthier attitudes toward success and failure. With support from coaches and sports psychologists, they can learn to embrace imperfection, bounce back from setbacks, and enjoy the game more. Let's work together to find a better way to play!

How perfectionism impacts performance

In the world of sports, perfectionism can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it can push athletes to strive for excellence and achieve great success. On the other hand, it can also lead to stress, anxiety, and burnout, hindering performance in the long run. Let's take a closer look at how perfectionism can both help and hinder athletes:

Positive Impacts of Perfectionism:

  • Motivation: Perfectionism can serve as a powerful motivator, driving athletes to work hard and continuously improve their skills.

  • Attention to Detail: Perfectionistic athletes often pay close attention to the finer details of their performance, leading to greater precision and accuracy.

  • High Standards: Setting high standards for oneself can push athletes to reach their full potential and strive for excellence in their sport.

Negative Impacts of Perfectionism:

  • Fear of Failure: Perfectionistic athletes may be afraid of making mistakes or falling short of their own or others' expectations, leading to anxiety and performance anxiety.

  • Self-Criticism: Constantly striving for perfection can lead to harsh self-criticism and negative self-talk, which can undermine confidence and enjoyment of the sport.

  • Burnout: The relentless pursuit of perfection can take a toll on athletes' physical and mental well-being, leading to burnout and decreased motivation over time.

While perfectionism can fuel achievement and success in the short term, it's essential for athletes to recognize its potential downsides and find a balance that allows for growth and enjoyment of the sport. By understanding the ways in which perfectionism can both help and hinder performance, athletes can work with coaches and sports psychologists to develop healthier attitudes and strategies for success. Let's explore how athletes can navigate the complexities of perfectionism to reach their full potential on and off the field.

perfectionism in sports

9 tips for managing perfectionism in sports

I will share a variety of strategies to help athletes manage perfectionism in sports. Whether you're a player or a coach, there are techniques you can use to find a healthier balance and improve performance. I will provide strategies for coaches to support their athletes and for athletes to implement on their own. Let's explore how to overcome perfectionism and enjoy the game to its fullest!

Strategies for coaching perfectionistic athletes 

Helping athletes manage perfectionism requires a combination of support, understanding, and practical strategies. Here are some techniques coaches and parents can use to help athletes navigate perfectionistic tendencies:

  1. Encourage a Growth Mindset: Teach athletes to embrace a growth mindset, where mistakes are seen as opportunities for learning and improvement rather than failures. By fostering a mindset focused on progress rather than perfection, athletes can approach challenges with resilience and determination.

  2. Set Realistic Goals: Work with athletes to set realistic, achievable goals that focus on effort, improvement, and personal development rather than solely on outcomes. Breaking larger goals into smaller, manageable steps can help athletes stay motivated and track their progress over time.

  3. Promote Positive Self-Talk: Encourage athletes to cultivate positive self-talk and challenge negative thoughts and beliefs. Help them develop affirmations and mantras that reinforce their strengths, resilience, and ability to overcome setbacks.

  4. Create a Supportive Environment: Foster a supportive and inclusive team environment where athletes feel valued, accepted, and encouraged to be themselves. Emphasize the importance of teamwork, cooperation, and mutual support in achieving collective goals.

  5. Teach Coping Strategies: Provide athletes with a toolkit of coping strategies to help them manage stress, anxiety, and perfectionistic tendencies. Techniques such as deep breathing, visualization, and mindfulness can help athletes stay calm and focused during competitions.

  6. Celebrate Effort and Progress: Recognize and celebrate athletes' efforts and progress, regardless of the outcome. Reinforce the idea that success is not solely defined by winning or achieving perfection but by the dedication, resilience, and growth demonstrated along the way.

  7. Encourage Self-Compassion: Teach athletes to be kind and compassionate toward themselves, especially in moments of failure or disappointment. Help them recognize that everyone makes mistakes and that self-compassion is essential for resilience and well-being.

  8. Provide Feedback Wisely: Offer constructive feedback in a supportive and encouraging manner, focusing on areas for improvement while also acknowledging athletes' strengths and accomplishments. Be mindful of the language used and the impact it can have on athletes' self-esteem and confidence.

  9. Model Healthy Behavior: Lead by example and model healthy attitudes and behaviors toward success, failure, and perfectionism. Share personal experiences and struggles with perfectionism to show athletes that it's okay to make mistakes and that growth comes from embracing imperfection.

Strategies that perfectionistic athletes can use on their own

If you're an athlete struggling with perfectionism, there are several strategies you can use to manage these tendencies and improve your performance:

  • Focus on Effort, Not Perfection: Shift your focus from achieving perfection to giving your best effort in every practice and competition. Recognize that mistakes are a natural part of the learning process and an opportunity for growth and improvement.

  • Set Realistic Goals: Set goals that are challenging yet attainable, breaking them down into smaller, manageable steps. By setting realistic goals, you can reduce the pressure to be perfect and celebrate progress along the way.

  • Practice Self-Compassion: Be kind and compassionate toward yourself, especially when things don't go as planned. Treat yourself with the same understanding and support that you would offer to a teammate facing similar challenges.

  • Challenge Negative Thoughts: Challenge negative thoughts and beliefs about perfectionism by replacing them with more realistic and positive affirmations. Remind yourself that nobody is perfect and that making mistakes is an essential part of the learning process.

  • Use Visualization: Visualize success by mentally rehearsing successful performances and overcoming challenges. Visualization can help you build confidence, reduce anxiety, and improve your ability to perform under pressure.

  • Focus on the Process: Shift your focus from the outcome of your performance to the process of preparation and execution. By focusing on the steps you need to take to succeed, you can stay present and perform to the best of your abilities.

  • Develop Coping Strategies: Learn and practice coping strategies such as deep breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness to help you manage stress and anxiety during competitions.

  • Seek Support: Reach out to coaches, teammates, or a sports psychologist for support and guidance. Talking to others about your struggles with perfectionism can help you feel understood and supported, and they may offer valuable insights and strategies for managing these tendencies.

  • Celebrate Progress: Celebrate your progress and accomplishments, no matter how small. Acknowledge your efforts and improvements along the way, and remember that growth and development take time and persistence.

By implementing these strategies and practicing self-awareness and self-compassion, you can learn to manage perfectionism and thrive as an athlete. Remember that nobody is perfect, and embracing your imperfections can ultimately lead to greater success and fulfillment in your athletic pursuits.

In my experience as a clinical sport psychologist

With over a decade in competitive sports, I see perfectionism almost daily. On such example is Sarah, a talented teenage girl who excels in competitive cheerleading. Despite her skill and dedication, Sarah was struggling with perfectionism, often feeling overwhelmed by the pressure to perform flawlessly. Recognizing the impact of perfectionism on Sarah's confidence and performance, her coach suggested she work with a sport psychologist specializing in mental skills training. Through a series of one-on-one sessions, I worked with l Sarah identify the negative thought patterns and behaviors fueling her perfectionistic tendencies. Together, we developed personalized strategies to manage perfectionism and build resilience. I introduced Sarah to techniques such as mindfulness, positive self-talk, and goal setting, empowering her to shift her focus from achieving perfection to giving her best effort. Over time, Sarah learned to embrace mistakes as learning opportunities and celebrate her progress rather than fixating on outcomes. With my guidance and support, as well as the support of her coach and parents, Sarah gained confidence, found joy in her performances, and achieved greater success in competitive cheerleading.

perfectionism in sport

Break free from the mindsets that keep you from reaching peak performance. 

Navigating perfectionism can be challenging, but you don't have to do it alone. At Excel Sport Psychology, I am here to support you on your journey to overcoming perfectionism and achieving your goals in sports. Through personalized consultations, I can help you implement the strategies discussed in this post and provide customized recommendations tailored to your specific needs and challenges. Whether you're an athlete struggling with perfectionism or a coach/parent seeking to support your athletes, I'm here to provide guidance, encouragement, and practical solutions. If you're interested in working with me to combat perfectionism and unlock your full potential in sports, don't hesitate to reach out. Together, we can develop a plan to help you thrive in your athletic pursuits. Schedule a free phone consultation today.

3 views0 comments


bottom of page